Review of Supernatural 9×04, “Slumber Party”
After all of the drama of last week’s episode, it was a relief to be treated to such an enjoyable story as “Slumber Party.” No major controversies or soul-crushing moments (sad, yes, but nothing that one couldn’t get off the floor from); just a fun adventure to get lost in for an hour, with an ending as awesome as the song that accompanied it.
After figuring out a way to possibly track the angels, Sam (Jared Padalecki) discovers a computer room in the bunker. While showing it to Dean (Jensen Ackles), the older Winchester accidentally (and unknowingly) knocks over a jar, releasing its contents. The Winchesters then call in Charlie (Felicia Day) to rig the ancient computer to track angels, only to later discover the newly released Dorothy (Tiio Horn)–yes, of The Wizard of Oz fame–and learn that the Wicked Witch of the West (Maya Massar) is now free as well. Thus begins the hunt for the witch before she get return to Oz and wreak havoc once more.
While the plot itself was well constructed (including a very nicely done reference to the relics Dean was looking at in “Goodbye, Stranger” from last season,) the thematic elements caught my attention the most. Season nine has been four for four thus far in presenting instances of possession and consent, this time with the Wicked Witch’s power to take control of victims (so if anyone was still wondering if this was going to be a seasonal trend, I would say this confirms it.) The issue of choice and consequences continues. Dean’s decisions have been the focus so far – his choices have had great impact on Sam and Castiel. In this episode it was Charlie’s turn to have Dean decide her fate, and now the lies Dean has told are starting to catch up with him. Both Charlie and Sam suspect that something is up, and when the truth comes out Dean’s going to have to face some undoubtedly unpleasant ramifications.
Contrast also featured prominently throughout the episode. We saw the difference between life in the Men of Letters bunker in 1935 and in the present, with even the dialogue style and cinematography distinguishing the two time periods. The distinction between the Hunters (the soldiers in the fight against the supernatural) and the Men of Letters (who could be dubbed the generals), was illustrated both through Dorothy’s interactions with the two men in 1935 and then even more clearly with Charlie. Finally, Sam’s perspective versus Dean’s perspective on the bunker were both enunciated by the pair, and also displayed via their choice of mattress (Sam’s being utilitarian as opposed to Dean’s comfort-emphasizing memory foam.) For Sam, the bunker is a place of work; for Dean, it’s home.
The major overarching theme in this episode, though, was “adventure.” The episode begins with the young Man of Letters excited about the prospect of adventure, only to told by his elder that it’s something to avoid, which unfortunately proves true for the young man. Charlie parallels this, being the youngest of the group and wishing that she could have a quest of her own. She gets her wish (albeit, to use her words, less “magical” and “more intense,”) with a good old fashioned monster hunt, complete with puzzles and fetch quests. Unlike the young Man of Letters, Charlie’s desire for adventure doesn’t end on a tragic note, but on a triumphant one, with AC/DC’s “For Those About to Rock” sending her and Dorothy on their way.
Supernatural isn’t known, of course, for its feel-good episodes. So when they come around, they are to be treasured. This one could not have been more timely. It was reminder of all that we love about this show, even including those moments of heartbreak and angst. Regardless of how one felt about last week episode, “Slumber Party” was more than worthy of being applauded. And for that, Supernatural cast and crew, I salute you.
Read our before commenting.
Do not copy our content in whole to other websites. Linkbacks are encouraged.
Copyright © The Geekiary
6 thoughts on “Review of Supernatural 9×04, “Slumber Party””
I agree entirely. This episode was such a relief. Felt damn good after 3 episodes in a row that left me so depressed and/or angry. Robbie Thompson continues to be my favorite writer and Felicia Day my favorite guest star (Misha is a “regular” now otherwise he’d have that title).
Another AMAZING episode. So many zinger lines-Felicia Day was wonderful as Charlie, as always. Tiio Horn gave a multi-faceted performance as Dorothy. Loved the “retelling” by Dorothy of the true Wizard of Oz story. Fun episode-hope we get to see both Charlie & Dorothy again soon. Really loved the many new rooms in the MOL bunker-especially the garage (a home for “Baby”) and the 1951 computer. Especially loved the last scenes-the yellow brick road and Sam’s line “There’s no place like home”. And the special effects were tremendous.
I enjoyed your recap Leo. For all the reason you have already stated Slumber Party is one of my new favorite SPN episodes. I like the alternate dimensions and parallel universes we sometimes get in this show. Robbie Thompson and Adam Glass have written some of the best scripts so far.
excellent synopsis of the show….I agree wholeheartedly. This is going to be one of my favorites for sure
I really enjoyed the episode as well. It left me with a sort of weird aftertaste though. They sent their only openly gay recurring character, a “friend of Dorothy,” literally over the rainbow with Dorothy to have her own adventures. Away from the show. It was left open-ended, but also seemed to be a sort of possible conclusion to Charlie’s story on Supernatural. At first I was excited, thinking maybe the proposed spin-off would be with these two. Alas, no such luck. So, I have very mixed feelings. I was so excited seeing two well developed female characters work together on this show and I thought of all the possibilities for it and then…then they both left for Oz where only they have the key and as far as we know, no way to contact the Winchesters and vice versa.
Comments are closed.