Supernatural 11×5 Review: Thin Lizzie


It’s hard to follow up an episode like ‘Baby.’  Last week is sure to go down as one of the most memorable episodes of Supernatural, so it’s unfair to call this episode mediocre after riding the high from such an incredible episode.  If I can dig myself out of that enthusiasm, I can see this episode for the well-structured, entertaining episode that it is and admit I actually quite enjoyed it.  I’ve always thought the Lizzie Borden case interesting, so even though it started as a Monster-of-the-Week episode, I figured it’d at the very least be something moderately intriguing.  I was surprised to see a MOW episode relate back to the main arc, though.  Usually MOW episodes are completely isolated.  While I’m not particularly fond of the Darkness arc, I still think it’s a great change of pace.

Most of you know that I’m a huge Cas fan.  He wasn’t in this episode, but I still found myself happy with how he was included into the overarching plot despite his physical absence.  The fandom has come up with the term “Cas-nesia” to explain how the show continually forgets Castiel’s existence.  Thankfully this season they seem to be keeping him in the brother’s minds even when he doesn’t play directly into the plot.  I’d rather Cas be back at the bunker marathoning The Wire than forgotten about or set adrift on his own with no friends or home.  So Cas wasn’t in the episode, but he wasn’t forgotten about and that’s a massive improvement from the last couple of seasons.  Thank you, writers. Well done.

As far as the Darkness arc, I’m not sold on it quite yet.  It still reminds me of the disturbing Renesmee story from the Twilight franchise.  Her adult form was highly sexualized and ‘imprinted’ on Dean. Then she was a baby, a child, and now a pre-teen and her and Dean still have a ‘connection’ of some sort.  Still super creepy, guys.  However, I was intrigued by the side characters and the exploration of how soullessness effects the human body.  Cindy was much more similar to the soulless people we’ve met before.  She feels free and commits heinous crimes in revenge for the pain she felt when she still had a soul.  Len, however, feels depressed and detached.  Len is not the traditional soulless killing machine that we’ve grown used to.

SPN2There’s some speculation that this episode implied that Dean may be soulless.  I’m not entirely sure I believe that theory.  The constant “going through the motions” commentary by Len and Dean’s joke about killing the people they are supposed to be saving seem to be the biggest hints people have about soulless Dean, but that’s not enough to tip me over the edge on this theory.  He’s been depressed before and still had a soul.

Overall, not a bad episode.  Not exactly super memorable or noteworthy, but a decent follow up to a remarkable episode that’ll go down in Supernatural fandom history books.  It wasn’t useless despite being a filler episode, had interesting side characters, and respected the secondary cast even when they weren’t on the screen.  It gives me faith that some of the other filler episodes from the season could have potential.

Author: Angel Wilson

Angel is the admin of The Geekiary and a geek culture commentator. They earned a BA in Film & Digital Media from UC Santa Cruz. They have contributed to various podcasts and webcasts including An Englishman in San Diego, Free to Be Radio, and Genre TV for All. They identify as queer.

Help support independent journalism. Subscribe to our Patreon.

Copyright © The Geekiary

Do not copy our content in whole to other websites. If you are reading this anywhere besides, it has been stolen.
Read our policies before commenting. Be kind to each other.

4 thoughts on “Supernatural 11×5 Review: Thin Lizzie

  1. What is MOW?

    “Cas wasn’t in the episode, but he wasn’t forgotten about and that’s a massive improvement from the last couple of seasons. Thank you, writers. Well done.” Agree. And thank you, writers.

    To keep it short and avoid repeatative, I’d say I’m totally agree with what you said up there. That’s what I saw from the episode too. Except I like the darkness concept, but the way she has a special connection toward Dean; I have to say that I want to wait till something more happen before I decided to go against it. To think about that, it kinda remind me of the connection between Dean and Cas through Cas’s hand print on Dean’s upper arm when he dragged Dean out of Hell in season 4. I know that in the show there was nothing going on with it. The potential started from the fandom.

  2. Wait! Can I say that Cas’s handprint on Dean is the sign of him frees Dean from Hell while the F mark on Amara is the sign of she got her freedom back from being lock up behind the door/key/lock which is Dean? It makes more sense than the Twilight theory although I’ve not watched it I heard about the ‘that from some friends.

Comments are closed.