Supernatural 9×11 Review: First Born

SPN1As upset as I was with the Winchesters parting ways yet again, this split has offered opportunities for rarely seen character dynamics to thrive.  Mark Sheppard and Jensen Ackles nailed it tonight and I was thrilled with every scene they shared together.  Misha Collins and Jared Padalecki also had a lot of fabulous scenes in tonight’s episode.  Despite the fact that Misha is my favorite actor on the show, I feel like their scenes were definitely second to the amazing chemistry between Ackles and Sheppard.  Amazing performances all around.  The episode wasn’t without its problems, though.  Once again the show introduces a promising female character only to take all of our hopes away.  As incredible as the rest of the episode was, this whole situation really put a bad taste in my mouth.


SPN3My favorite moments of the episode all came from Crowley and Dean.  Crowley is definitely evil.  He’s an antagonist and he’s killed people and that’s not something that can be overlooked.  Morally I should be completely against him teaming up with the Winchesters for anything, but this doesn’t stop me from enjoying every moment that he’s on screen.  Once again I find myself desperately wishing he wasn’t so darn evil so that he could actually be a permanent member of Team Free Will.  He adds a sardonic humor to every scene he’s in that I find incredibly appealing.  There’s always a dark humor running throughout the show generally, but the dryness of Crowley’s quips are hard to beat.  In season 5 Crowley teamed up with them to take out Lucifer and now he’s teaming up with them to go after Abbadon.  It seems that if you compare him to the other evils that exist in the world, he’s definitely the lesser of them.  He’s still evil, though, and as viewers it’s easy to forget that as we get lost in Mark Sheppard’s amazing performance.


Jared Padalecki and Misha Collins are always fabulous together, but they rarely get scenes alone.  In the past this has been blamed on their penchant for playing pranks on each other on set and I am no doubt looking forward to the gag reel, but this has come at a sacrifice of the characters’ relationship.  This episode more than made up for it though.  Castiel has learned a vital lesson thanks to a combination of the Winchesters and a peanut butter and jelly sandwich.  Castiel has grown as a person over the years and no longer has the same outlook he did even as recently as last season.  The ends no longer always justify the means for him.  Sam and Castiel bond over their shared trait of screwing things up and their friendship develops into something even stronger than it was before.  I’m looking forward to more.


SPN2Unfortunately this episode didn’t thrill me all the way through.  This season has continued with the very strong trend of killing off their new strong female characters within the episode they are introduced and I was hoping we’d start moving away from that.  As soon as a new strong female character was presented to us I began pleading “please don’t die.”  This episode was written by Robbie Thompson and he generally treats his female characters fairly well so I had high hopes.  He’s the one that created Charlie, after all, and he crafted Dorothy into an incredibly badass character just a few episodes ago.  Even the writer that I hold in such high regard isn’t immune from the occasional misstep it seems.  If this had been the first instance of the season where this occurred I may have been more forgiving, but the show itself has a bad history of this exact type of thing and I’ve become hyper aware of just how often it happens.


Despite the mistreatment of the new female character, the episode did manage to introduce a new male character that shows a lot of promise.  Cain is being framed as a surprisingly intriguing ally given that he’s typically framed as a simplistic villain.  Once more Supernatural has taken religious lore and twisted it in a fresh new way.  It seems as though he’ll be playing a vital part in this seasons overarching plot, which seems to be shifting focus now that we’ve reached the halfway point.  Whereas during the first half of the season the fallen angels and Gadreel dominated the ongoing plot, it seems the battle between Crowley and Abbadon is taking center stage for the back half.  I’m generally happy with the shift in focus as the first half of the season was very disappointing and I love both Crowley and Abbadon, but I am sad that this means the chances of seeing Tahmoh Penikett reprise his role as Gadreel is getting slimmer.

SPN4Overall this episode was far better than almost any episode in the first half of the season.  I’m disappointed that the brothers are still apart and that the trend of mistreating female characters is continuing, but there’s a lot of promise for the back half of season 9 to improve.  In order to keep this momentum going they need to focus on what they want the central plot to be, add some permanent female energy in the dynamic (bring back Jodie or Charlie, perhaps?), and get the Winchesters back together.  Once they get these issues sorted season 9 can live up to the expectations Supernatural fans have set for the show that we love so much.

Author: Angel Wilson

Angel is the admin of The Geekiary and a geek culture commentator. They earned a BA in Film & Digital Media from UC Santa Cruz. They have contributed to various podcasts and webcasts including An Englishman in San Diego, Free to Be Radio, and Genre TV for All. They’ve also written for Friends of Comic Con and is a 2019 Hugo Award winner for contributing fanfic on AO3. They identify as queer.


Read our policies before commenting.
Do not copy our content in whole to other websites. Linkbacks are encouraged.
Copyright © The Geekiary

4 thoughts on “Supernatural 9×11 Review: First Born

  1. Adored Cain, continue to adore Crowley and Castiel, glad Sam’s getting back to his old sweet self. And Dean can keep that ginger facial hair if you ask me.

  2. As soon as she started in with the ‘well didn’t you grow up pretty’ (UGH) and the unflattering and teeth-grindingly judgmental comparison between Dean and John I didn’t give half a crap what happened to her. I think they actually set a new record at making me dislike a character in minimum time.

    1. Fair enough. I can definitely see how that could rub people the wrong way. My view of her may have just been tainted because I foresaw her death the moment she entered the screen. My “please let this woman survive” drive made her much more sympathetic and heroic than she may have been otherwise.

      -Admin Angel

  3. I saw them fridge another woman and thought to myself “Man . . . the Geekiary is going to NOT like that!” I’m glad to see you didn’t let me down! This continuing trend within Supernatural is damaging, and painful as a female viewer to watch a lot of the time. Unfortunately, as much as I love Robbie from Twitter interactions, and as great as it was that he gave us Charlie, it’s not something he’s innocent of within the show–after all, he is the writer who also offed Meg, the longest running female character, and then sent Charlie skipping off to Oz.

    Also, I’ve noticed that he has a tendency to over-write Castiel at times. The peanut butter sandwich intervention speech was a good example of that: it was a great sentiment, that I very much appreciated. . . but with that character, the monologue felt clunky. I love Cas dearly, and like you I appreciate Misha’s acting ability, but they beat us over the head with it in that monologue.

    While I understand Cas doesn’t have the “bond” with Sam that he does with Dean, where huge moments like the trenchcoat it would have been superfluous to over-script that, I think a little could have gone a long way, and a lot put it over-the-top. This directly contrasts with Crowley/Dean because it’s their barbed interactions that really made their scenes a joy to watch.

    Overall, I can’t fault any of the actors though. Their performances were great. Love seeing Jared be able to play SAM again, love having Castiel and Sam bond, Dean is a scary Mo-Fo and breaks my heart, and we just can’t help enjoying Crowley despite the fact that he is unabashedly evil.

    I’m excited about the Cain subplot. There’s a lot of rich mythology that they can play with in typical SPN fashion. I really hope the second half of the season picks up the slack from the first part.

    (That said. . . REALLY not excited about next episode, based on the previews)

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: