Secret Empire #1 Puts Shock Value Above Soldiers And That’s A Problem

Unless you’ve been living under a rock in the Dark Dimension (actually, even there) you’ve heard the news: Captain America, beloved hero and all-around good guy, is Hydra in the current story line. At C2E2 this weekend I had a chance to read an advance copy of Secret Empire #1 and… well, you know what site you’re on, guys. There are FEELINGS.

Full disclosure: I’m well-known in my circle for my deep love of Captain America. I loved Cap when I was a kid and his main appeal was the cool costume and shield. In my Army days, I would tag along on trips to the main base in hopes that one of the new cheesy-but-awesome special military edition Marvel comics was out. When the MCU got to Winter Soldier, I fell in love all over again from the way they portrayed Cap: torn between loyalties, faithful to his country but uneasy at the direction it’s taking and no longer sure what’s wrong or right.

A lot of my fellow veterans feel the same way. We feel this way because to us – to the military and to veterans – Captain America is one of us. Steven Grant Rogers is a symbol of every soldier who gives their all to a government that plays fast and loose with that loyalty.

That’s kind of a metaphor for what Marvel is doing with him right now, actually.

See, the problem isn’t that the writing throughout this story arc is bad. That loose-leaf early copy of Secret Empire #1 I got to read? I mean… I’m a comics fan at heart, people. I know good writing when I see it, and this is good writing. Amid the devastation wrought by the utter debasement of a beautiful character, other characters that don’t get as much love as they should are stepping into the light. Female characters and POCs seem to be carrying the heroic torch throughout the Secret Empire, and I do like seeing that kind of representation.

Except, as I said, quality of writing isn’t the problem. It’s actually the opposite case. If the writing was bad – if Nick Spencer was a hack with no talent – none of this would matter. I could write this off with an eye roll as a lazy “but what if the good guy was… BAD?” story line and move on with my day.

The problem is this: Marvel is denying responsibility for having connected soldiers and Captain America. They’re pretending they didn’t deliberately cultivate a sense of brotherhood with the Star Spangled Man With A Plan, and by doing that they can’t see that this story is flourishing at the expense of soldiers.

Maybe that statement seems like I’m overreacting. I’ll grant that it’s a possibility. I certainly don’t speak for all veterans here. I did talk to some of my nerdy veteran friends about this, though, and if I’m taking it too seriously so are they. Our less comic-centric battle buddies are trying to remind us that it’s not about us, that Captain America isn’t about us, but Marvel has gone so far out of their way to build a connection between Cap and the military that it’s almost ridiculous.

Those comics we got while deployed? They showed Captain America and friends as among us, fighting beside us, doing the things we did but also kind of deferring to us as experts in our field. Over and over again we were shown that Cap is one of us. It’s not a leap to return that with “we are Cap”. I watched Chris Evans throughout Winter Soldier and Civil War and thought, “Me too, man. Me, too.” I have also had to navigate conflicting loyalties between battle buddies and the government. I felt those stories to my bones.

Not this one. For the first time, Captain America is someone I can’t like, let alone love.

I can’t fully divorce myself from him, either, and that’s double-plus ungood.

When you identify with Cap like so many of us do – like we were encouraged to do – and he turns into this, it can put you in a dark place. You start looking uneasily at your past for things you could have done better, places you made the wrong choice. Do I logically regret anything I did overseas? Nope, not one. Mine was a fairly tame experience as deployments go – but still, this story line has cost me sleep in a bad way. (Thanks, Marvel. I really needed one more thing keeping me awake.)

Even worse is the fact that Captain America didn’t have to be innately evil to create an interesting story. My veteran buddies and I would be all aboard a story arc where Cap is suffering from worsening PTSD and the government is hushing it up to preserve their hero’s reputation. Bam, Cap can do some bad things without being bad.

So where do we go from here?

I could ignore this entire label until Secret Empire ends – but there’s another problem. Marvel has been criticized for linking the increase in minority titles to poor sales (because clearly people aren’t just mad/bored/offended by Nazi Cap). By ignoring the entire Secret Empire, I might be hurting amazing talent like Margaret Stohl. Seriously, if you haven’t read her work go do the thing, because I’d give my left arm just to listen to her personal headcanons about Captain Marvel or Black Widow.

I brought my concerns up at the C2E2 Secret Empire panel. Everyone hurried to reassure me that that wasn’t the intent. Nick Lowe, who is a sunshiney dude you could easily picture hanging out with on Read Comics In Public Day, told me his grandfather was a Vietnam veteran. Margaret Stohl explained at length about how offending veterans wasn’t the point and how it was about the growth of the character that mattered. Everyone swore the payoff in the end is worth it. Nick Spencer came in with a pointed statement along the lines of, “This isn’t Cap’s fault. There was nothing he could to do prevent this, he had no choice, it wasn’t his fault.”

That last part, spoken what felt like directly to me, actually made me feel better for a few minutes… until I sat on it for a while and realized that didn’t answer my problem. It was my problem. What Marvel meant to do doesn’t matter. What matters is that Captain America doesn’t have a choice. He’s a pawn, available for whoever wants to play with him and easily manipulated to do even the worst things in the name of his chief virtues. He is without autonomy in this arc. This is how people see soldiers – wind them up and they do whatever you want.

And honestly, f–k that.

I would have felt ten times better if, upon hearing that question, the panel had reacted more along the lines of, “Oh no, oh my gods, we did not think of that angle and yeah, I get that. We’re already doing the story and we have to play it out but guys, we’re so sorry, we just didn’t get it.” You know, some validation or an admission that they hadn’t seen that angle. All I wanted to know was that my favorite comic producer hadn’t weighed the pain they were about to cause a socially vulnerable population and decided it was worth it.

Did they? Who knows? It’s unlikely. These people aren’t monsters, however mad I am about this. Probably they didn’t think it through and aren’t willing to admit it, which is a jerk move but whatever.

Where do we go from here? Honestly, I’m not sure. Will my profound love of Captain America survive if I read more of this story? Do I trust that Marvel will have some kind of climax that makes me not want to jump off a bridge in self loathing? Can I indulge in a little magical thinking and decide that Captain America is being held hostage by a foreign force in the form of his alternate self?

One thing is certain. Captain America will never – can never – be as pure as he was.

Apparently I’m the only person who thinks that’s a bad thing.

How do you feel about Captain America’s heel turn? Am I full of it, or do you see where I’m coming from on this angle? Share your thoughts in the comment section below.

Author: Khai

Khai is a writer, anthropologist, and games enthusiast. She is co-editor (alongside Alex DeCampi) of and contributor to “True War Stories”, a comic anthology published by Z2 Comics. When she’s not writing or creating games, Khai likes to run more tabletop RPGs than one person should reasonably juggle.

Help support independent journalism. Subscribe to our Patreon.

Copyright © The Geekiary

Do not copy our content in whole to other websites. If you are reading this anywhere besides, it has been stolen.
Read our policies before commenting. Be kind to each other.

8 thoughts on “Secret Empire #1 Puts Shock Value Above Soldiers And That’s A Problem

  1. Very well put. What marvel has done is incredibly disrespectful and they’ve only compounded the mess by refusing to acknowledge why people are upset.

  2. I understand where you’re coming from. I love Cap and this arc has been really different. Probably the most interesting story coming out from Marvel at the moment. The unexpected nature of the series is a highlight. I’m not a vet. I’m looking at it from the angle that these characters need to go through their own form of hell to show that they can overcome it and that the people who read the stories can believe in themselves to do the same. The arc is not about destroying what cap stands for. I think It’s about showing that the thing we hold as being incorruptible (Steve Rogers, the pinnacle of what heroism is) can be corrupted and from an introspective point, highlights the impact of this. Marvel didn’t cross a line, they own the rights to do what ever they want with their characters. You might disagree with the direction but this is a story about how even Cap can fall and become the thing he has spent years fighting against. It happens in all mediums, the Greeks had tragedies, the romans, the vikings, why should we in the modern age be different. This story will, I hope, take Cap on a redemption arc, dealing with the fallout of the story. The disrespect is in the bashing and threats that the writer has received.

    1. Of course Marvel owns Captain America and can do as they wish. It’s still irresponsible to ruin Captain America- and friend, they are ruining him. He will never again be the standard by which we can judge right or wrong because of the way they structured this story.

      See, Captain America wasn’t corrupted in this storyline. That’s not was happened. He was ALWAYS EVIL. The Good Cap is the fiction, has always been the fiction. This means that Cap was NEVER GOOD, he was always a fiction created by heroes in another dimension to save their world from his evil true self. He was so incorruptible because other heroes worked to make a hero so noble he could never be corrupted.

      If (When?) Captain America is permanently restored to his glorious fictional self, he doesn’t need a redemption arc. Nick Spencer told me to my face that this was not Steve’s fault, that he had no way to fight or resist or defend against what happened to him. This means Steve’s entire self was basically stolen, used, and abused. When Steve comes back, he doesn’t need a redemption arc.

      He needs -for lack of better description- a rape survivor arc.

  3. I hadn’t considered it from a vet’s point of view, but I feel much the same way about Captain America. I feel like what Marvel has done not only craps on his history as a character, but on the creators of the character as well. And I have to wonder that, if Captain America reflects what America is, what doing this is meant to say about us. That we’ve become Nazis? Or that we’ve become obsessed with the big twist reveal?

  4. I am not a veteran except when it comes to reading comics, which is most of my almost 41 years. Despite being Canadian, Captain America was always a favourite. He was like Superman or Supergirl, a character that resonated as someone to aspire to, to have hope and to always seek out truth and justice. Steve’s origin was always known as someone who was inspired to help others, even at the possible cost of his own life, and he worked hard to ensure that when he survived the experiment he would help put an end to the war. While he was being looked up to by in-story soldiers, he too was inspired by them. Captaiin America punching Hitler on his first appearance cover is iconic, and as with the entirety of the Golden Age of comic books, the heroes were out there to inspire people to hope for a better tomorrow and escape for a while from the dark world that is out there. So, from his inception, the character of Captain America was a symbol against terrorism/ prejudice/ hatred.

    What Marvel is doing with this storyline is taking that character and insulting every customer who bought a book with Steve Rogers and was inspired by him, insulting every child who took a garbage can lid and pretended they were him, insulting soldiers who have fought and are still fighting by suggesting that a character they might have looked up to is nothing more than a manipulated puppet of a larger organization, who needed help in being “a good guy,” but is actually evil. If they’re not going to stick with that, then they are insulting customers by trying to buy into another big event that “will change the Marvel Universe forever” when they are admitting things will be okay at the end.

    I don’t see how this will make Steve Rogers’ character more “fleshed out” or what have you as they have already done similar stunts with morality by having Steve no longer want to be a “drug user” and had all his Super-Soldier Serum removed, making him more aligned with Batman as someone who used his training to help mould him rather than an outside source. As you mentioned, why not write a story where the “perfect” Cap has to deal with PTSD, give him a service dog, or something along those lines if they want to ground Cap with greater realism, or show new readers how dealing with being in a world that isn’t his is or has been difficult, but in the end, there’s hope to continue living?

    This might have been a great storyline had it simply been a “What if?” or multiverse scenario. Have that “our” Cap and “our” heroes have to deal with a Captain America who is evil, who is willing to risk taking on himself in order to try to wipe out this existence. That would allow Steve to look at himself, quite literally, and figuratively, at what made and makes him a hero, and why he *didn’t* end up like that version of him. Other heroes would then have to look at our Cap with a greater respect or greater scrutiny, but it wouldn’t take away that overall Steve Rogers is and always will be an icon for truth and justice.

Comments are closed.