“Fantastic Four” Movie Review: Nothing Fantastic About It!

fantastic four teaser

I didn’t intend to see the new Fantastic Four film, but then the negative reviews started flooding in, and I was intrigued to see for myself why the film was being deemed awful. I thought that perhaps critics were overreacting and I might see something positive. Unfortunately, the moment the main characters came on screen and the plot became obvious, I knew the reason behind all those negative reviews.

This post contains spoilers about Fantastic Four so you might want to make like the Human Torch and fly away. You have been warned!

For me the Fantastic Four never worked as teenagers. I remember them as young adults from the comic books and that’s what I enjoyed about them. If I wanted to read about teenage superheroes I would pick up the Teen Titans. Sadly, director Josh Trank felt otherwise and Fantastic Four ended up looking like a poor man’s Chronicle, another superhero movie about super-powered teenagers by the same director.

Fantastic Four has always been about family, each member of the team contributing to keeping the team together over the years. This is something that was quite clear in the previous Fantastic Four series, but in the reboot the concept of family is nowhere to be found. Yes, Sue Storm (Kate Mara) and Johnny Storm are adoptive siblings but other than that there is no link between the main characters.

Speaking of Johnny Storm, when Michael B. Jordan was cast, people expressed their unease. I have no qualms about changing the race of a famous comic book character as long as the race isn’t a major part of the character to begin with. However, I still feel that writers need to create new POC fictional characters rather than changing the race of already established ones.

Having Johnny be played by Michael B. Jordan added diversity in the team, but what I couldn’t get over was how the black son had attitude problems and the white sister was a prim and proper daughter to Professor Franklin Storm. Even though the film tried to be different, it kind of missed the point by playing on a stereotype.

As far as the plot is concerned, if you can get over the main characters being teenagers, you mind end up enjoying it a bit. The problem I had with Reed Richards (Miles Teller) working with Sue, Johnny, and a disturbing version of Victor von Doom (Toby Kebbell), was that he forgot about his childhood best friend Ben Grimm (Jamie Bell). Though Reed invited him to explore the new dimension, the whole thing felt wrong to me because the boys forgot to invite Sue.

fantastic four posterThe boys talking about no one remembering the engineers who sent Neil Armstrong to the moon fell flat because they forgot to take the girl, who also worked on the project, with them. I think the writers didn’t want to bring Sue along because she would’ve tried to stop the boys. Frankly, her stopping them would’ve been the best thing to happen in the film!

After the painstaking origin stories, the rest of the film showed the characters being used as military assets trying to find Reed who escaped Area 57. They also wanted Reed back because without him the portal couldn’t be re-created. Again I rolled my eyes at the reasoning. Reed creating something ‘original’ made sense to me, but the world’s smartest engineers not being able to re-create something felt like plot convenience.

The main characters came together to become the Fantastic Four near the final 10 minutes of the film to take down Victor von Doom in the new dimension. I enjoyed the final fight, but I think that had more to do with not having anything enjoyable to see since the film started.

The Fantastic Four reboot would’ve fared well if it was a story about a couple of teenagers getting superhero powers and being used as military assets rather than a retelling of the origins of famous Marvel fictional characters.

Some random thoughts I would like to share:

  1. The Thing didn’t wear any clothes in the film but that’s nothing to be alarmed about because his anatomy doesn’t have anything to show. Think Groot from Guardians of the Galaxy.
  2. Ben’s backstory about being bullied by his brother and then copying the “It’s clobberin’ time” near the end of the film was just wrong. A character copying someone who bullied them is not character development as far as I know.
  3. I have no idea why Victor von Doom wanted to destroy Earth. Did he discover some sort of life in the new dimension? Because destroying Earth and then returning to the empty new dimension just doesn’t make sense. Victor von Doom in the comics wants to rule rather than destroy everything in sight for the sake of destroying.
  4. Fox needs to understand that a dark theme can work for the X-Men franchise because of the things it signifies in the real world about being outcast from society, etc. Making the new Fantastic Four dark was a huge mistake. Even the Chris Evans Fantastic Four films knew to make the whole thing light even though Earth was in danger.

A sequel’s date has been confirmed but with the current box-office numbers it might never come to fruition. Fantastic Four has clearly cemented its place as one of the worst superhero films ever. I mean the Halle Berry film Catwoman and even Elektra didn’t do well but at least I enjoyed watching those films. Fantastic Four felt like something that was haphazardly put together so Fox didn’t have to give the rights back to Marvel and have a superhero franchise other than the X-Men. I still believe that making a Fantastic Four Part 3 starring Jessica Alba and the rest would’ve been better. There’s still time, Fox; you can still revitalize the previous series!

Did you watch Fantastic Four? What did you think of it? Let us know!

Author: Farid-ul-Haq

Farid has a Double Masters in Psychology and Biotechnology as well as an M.Phil in Molecular Genetics. He is the author of numerous books including Missing in Somerville, and The Game Master of Somerville. He gives us insight into comics, books, TV shows, anime/manga, video games, and movies.

Help support independent journalism. Subscribe to our Patreon.

Copyright © The Geekiary

Do not copy our content in whole to other websites. If you are reading this anywhere besides TheGeekiary.com, it has been stolen.
Read our policies before commenting. Be kind to each other.

6 thoughts on ““Fantastic Four” Movie Review: Nothing Fantastic About It!

  1. Great review, Farid! I haven’t seen the film but I’ve read several reviews and yours is definitely another score against bothering with this movie, haha.

    1. Haha. Thanks! It was just bad. I think Fox is hoping for a profit overseas but then again I’m a ‘foreign’ viewer and you have already read what I thought of the film. I’ve talked to other viewers too and the biggest complain is Fox’s decision to make them teenagers and then giving it a dark theme. There’s a girl with Invisible Woman powers, a guy with Human Torch powers, another who can stretch (even change facial features), and a teenager who looks like The Thing but it’s just not the Fantastic Four. I hope Fox takes note and decides to make a part three of the previous series which were far better.

  2. I just watched this movie yesterday and I agree with everything you say in this article. Before seeing it, I heard mixed reviews from friends but wanted to see for myself. They could’ve done so much better. Maybe there’s hope for the sequel?

    1. Same here…I wasn’t expecting greatness from the film but I wasn’t expecting it to be this bad…I think I read producers saying that they hope to continue using these characters in Fox’s Marvel world, etc. and were mum about a sequel..i would rather that ignore this film and bring back the cast from the previous one.

  3. This is probably the first movie I have seen that has been panned by critics (professional and non) EVERYWHERE.That’s gotta be a record.

    Also, dark and gritty only works if it fits the theme. Batman, Daredevil, Constantine, The Punisher. Those have dark themes. F4? Not so much.

    1. Yup! I have no idea what the people at Fox were thinking when they made the decision to make a Fantastic Four movie (of all the movies!) with a dark theme…like no people! No!

Comments are closed.