X-Men #18 Review: A new Creative Team makes it better!


The Marvel NOW! X-Men re-launch showed great promise, being headlined by Brian Woods and featuring an all-female team. The excitement slowly diminished, however, and I have to admit the previous 17 issues have been a mess. With issue #18 the title is moving forward with a new creative team and it seems they might have what it takes to make the title a success.

It’s not as if I didn’t enjoy the previous issues. It had its fun moments and featured a growing romance between Mercury and Bling. I also enjoyed the team featuring Storm, Rachel, Psylocke, Jubilee, and Monet. But monthly issues felt as if they were moving too fast, especially during the recent arcs. The Battle of the Atom cross-over didn’t do it favors, and the team going to save Jubilee from The Future required an extra issue for a satisfactory conclusion.

It seems Marvel will be changing the momentum with a new creative team that includes Marc Guggenheim. He’s also the executive producer of the hit TV show Arrow. Where Woods’ run focused on new threats to the X-Men, Guggenheim went back into the X-Men lore and presented a very interesting premise.

1620739_283185151865293_7961038673859918461_nThe issue started with a flashback showing how Rachel’s family was terminated by the Shi’Ar because they saw the Grey family as a huge threat. It was immediately followed by the team taking on a mutating virus in the present day. I enjoyed the team dynamics; all of the members worked well together. There wasn’t any mention of the events from the previous issues so I think some time has passed since the ladies went to fight The Future.

It’s obvious that Guggenheim is familiar with the characters, and that’s why the whole issue works quite well. There’s hilarious banter in almost all of the panels and the team has a family dynamic, something that defines the X-Men. Dexter Soy’s artwork is a treat to look at, also. Ed Tadeo’s and Craig Yeung’s inkwork really give life to the panels. I think, however, I saw Jubilee use her mutant powers during one of the fight sequences. I don’t know if it was intentional or a mistake, because she hasn’t been able to use her powers ever since House of M, and turning into a vampire.

A problem I had with the story was making Deathbird pregnant. It could be that she consented to getting pregnant, but I’m tired of the trope. They even used her pregnancy as the shocking reveal that marked the end of the issue. I don’t know what’s up with writers making female characters pregnant whenever aliens are involved.

Guggenheim seems determined to provide readers with an exciting new adventure for the mutant ladies by sending them into space. I think X-Men #18 marks a new direction for the title and I’m interested in seeing if it does better than the previous issues.

Have you read X-Men #18 yet? What do you think of Marc Guggenheim’s take on the female team? Let us know in the comments!

Author: Farid-ul-Haq

Farid has a Double Masters in Psychology and Biotechnology as well as an M.Phil in Molecular Genetics. He is the author of numerous books including Missing in Somerville, and The Game Master of Somerville. He gives us insight into comics, books, TV shows, anime/manga, video games, and movies.

Help support independent journalism. Subscribe to our Patreon.

Copyright © The Geekiary

Do not copy our content in whole to other websites. If you are reading this anywhere besides TheGeekiary.com, it has been stolen.
Read our policies before commenting. Be kind to each other.

3 thoughts on “X-Men #18 Review: A new Creative Team makes it better!

  1. Not sure we read the same comic.
    Wood had tight character development not afraid to let a moment breathe and happen organically.
    What I am reading here is a writer nervous to not fill every scene with ‘youth’ references.
    Jubilee proclaims “I know Kung-fu” there’s an of the moment meme to Abigail brand needing to wrap things up so she can watch Game of Thrones.
    We get it you know what the kids want.
    It reads as desperate.
    Not to mention odd so Rachel uses an iPad huh?
    The x-men build time machines but still get their computers from the mall?
    Just another pop culture attempt.
    And while I am at it pretty sure Rachel or jean grey pulled that telepathy DL trick for jubilee before.
    Or was she so amazed at a hologram to make a joke about Star Trek?
    She’s been an x man for years.
    And this was all in the first four pages.
    Come on.
    Wood had a respect for the characters and the reader to not make such bad jokes on the first date like this.
    I hope it gets better.
    My grade for this is- out of touch C-

    1. I get what you mean…there was no need to mention Game of Thrones but i guess Marc wanted readers to relate to Abigail and smile that she has to watch hour long episodes in 15 minute intervals….kind of same for Jubilee and ‘i know kung-fu’…Matrix i believe…I think he will be making things more fun in his run compared to Woods, which for me, started to get a bit boring during the Arkea take down…sales have been declining for this title…I’m not saying that Marc’s take is perfect, however it’s different from Woods and if this difference helps in sales i’ll be happy with it…i don’t want Marvel to think an all female X-Men team can’t get good numbers and decide to end it

Comments are closed.